OEM vs Aftermarket Oil Filter: Which Should You Buy?

OEM and aftermarket oil filters on a workbench

An oil filter is a cheap part with an important job: catching the particles that would otherwise wear your engine’s bearings and moving parts.

You can buy the carmaker’s own (OEM) filter or one of many aftermarket brands. Here is how they really differ, what to look for and when each makes sense.

What you’ll learn

  • What OEM really means for filters
  • What matters inside a filter
  • Warranty rules
  • How to choose and fit one
Engine oilComparisonMaintenance

Quick answer

An OEM filter is made to your carmaker’s specification and is the safe default. A quality aftermarket filter from an established brand that lists your exact vehicle can match or exceed it, and some offer synthetic media for longer oil-change intervals. Avoid very cheap, unknown filters. Under the U.S. Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, a carmaker generally cannot void your warranty just because you used an aftermarket filter. What matters most is the correct fit, bypass valve setting and changing it on time.

Two oil filters side by side
From the outside, OEM and aftermarket filters can look almost identical; the differences are inside.

OEM vs aftermarket: what the terms mean

  • OEM: the filter sold under the carmaker’s brand, made to its specification by a supplier.
  • Aftermarket: any filter sold under another brand. Quality ranges from excellent to poor.
  • Many OEM filters are made by the same large filter companies that sell aftermarket lines.

The same idea applies to other parts; see OEM vs aftermarket alternators.

What matters inside an oil filter

  • Filter media: cellulose (paper), synthetic blend or full synthetic. Synthetic media holds more dirt and suits longer intervals.
  • Anti-drainback valve: keeps oil in the filter when the engine is off, so oil pressure builds quickly at startup. Silicone valves last longer than nitrile in heat.
  • Bypass (relief) valve: opens if the filter clogs or oil is cold. Its opening pressure must match what your engine expects.
  • Thread size and gasket: must match exactly, or the filter can leak.
  • Can strength and base plate: resist pressure spikes.
Cutaway view of an oil filter showing the media and valves
The filter media, anti-drainback valve and bypass valve are what separate a good filter from a poor one.

Filter makers test efficiency and capacity under the ISO 4548 standard; quality brands often publish ratings.

Will an aftermarket filter void my warranty?

In the U.S., the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act generally prevents a carmaker from voiding a warranty just because you used non-branded parts. The maker would have to show that the part caused the problem. Keep receipts and records of every oil change, whichever filter you use.

How to choose

  • Under warranty or unsure: the OEM filter is the simplest choice.
  • Normal intervals: a quality aftermarket filter from an established brand that lists your vehicle.
  • Extended synthetic oil intervals: a filter with synthetic media rated for the interval you use.
  • High-mileage engines: see the best oil filters for high-mileage cars.
  • Avoid: very cheap, unbranded filters with no published specs.

Fitting an oil filter correctly

  1. Make sure the old filter’s gasket came off with it; a doubled gasket will leak.
  2. Wipe the mounting surface clean.
  3. Put a thin film of fresh oil on the new gasket.
  4. Screw it on by hand until the gasket touches, then tighten about 3/4 to 1 more turn, or as printed on the filter.
  5. Refill with oil, run the engine briefly and check for leaks. See oil leak after an oil change.
Mechanic applying fresh oil to an oil filter gasket
A thin film of fresh oil on the gasket helps it seal and come off cleanly next time.

Change the filter with every oil change; see how often to change engine oil.

Changing your own oil? Our free DIY Job Planner lets you see the tools and supplies for an oil and filter change, tick what you already own, and see what you still need.

Related guides: OEM vs aftermarket alternator, aftermarket fuel injectors vs OEM, OEM vs aftermarket AC compressor and oil leak after an oil change.

Frequently asked questions

Are OEM oil filters better than aftermarket? +
Not always. OEM filters are a reliable default, but quality aftermarket filters can match or beat them. Cheap unbranded filters are the ones to avoid.
Will an aftermarket oil filter void my warranty? +
Generally no, in the U.S. Keep records of your oil changes.
Do I need a synthetic oil filter for synthetic oil? +
Not necessarily, but synthetic-media filters suit longer oil-change intervals.
Should I change the oil filter at every oil change? +
Yes, in almost all cases. It is cheap insurance.
How tight should an oil filter be? +
Hand-tight plus about 3/4 to 1 turn after the gasket touches, or as printed on the filter.

Sources

Similar Posts