A car security system can do three different jobs: make noise to scare a thief off, stop the engine from starting, or tell you where the car is after it’s taken. Most products only do one or two of these, so the right choice depends on what you’re worried about and how much installation you’re willing to do.
This guide compares five popular options, from professionally installed Viper alarms to a plug-in GPS tracker and a stick-on alarm you can fit in minutes, and explains what each type can and can’t do.
What you’ll learn
- The difference between alarms, immobilizers and trackers
- When a 1-way or 2-way remote matters
- Which systems need professional installation
- Which of five options suits your car and parking
Quick answer
For the strongest protection in a car without a modern factory immobilizer, an installed alarm with a starter kill, such as the Viper 350 PLUS 3105V, is the best value, and the Viper 5706V adds 2-way alerts and remote start. If your main worry is getting a stolen car back, a GPS tracker like CARLOCK is more useful than a siren. A stick-on vibration alarm is only a basic deterrent.
In this article
How to choose a car security system
Alarm, immobilizer or tracker?
An alarm makes noise and flashes lights when a door is opened or the car is bumped. An immobilizer or starter kill stops the engine from starting. A GPS tracker doesn’t prevent theft but shows where the car is and alerts your phone. Many factory systems already include an immobilizer, so check your owner’s manual before paying for one.
1-way vs 2-way remotes
A 1-way remote sends commands to the car. A 2-way remote also receives alerts back, so you know when the alarm goes off or the engine has started, even when you can’t hear the siren.
Installation
Wired alarms like Viper connect to the car’s electrical system and are normally fitted by a professional installer, which adds to the cost. Plug-in trackers and battery-powered alarms take minutes but offer less protection.
Range and alerts
Remote range matters if you park far from where you live or work. App-based trackers work anywhere with mobile coverage but may need a subscription; check the listing before you buy.
Battery drain
Any system that stays powered while the car is parked draws a small current. A faulty or badly installed alarm is a common cause of a battery that keeps dying.
Quick comparison
| Model | Type | Best for | Key features (from the maker’s listing) | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Viper 5706V 2-Way Security with Remote Start | Installed alarm + remote start | Full protection and remote start | 4-channel security; 2-way 5-button LCD remote; up to 1-mile range; remote start | Amazon |
| CARLOCK 4G Car Tracker and Alarm | GPS tracker | Knowing where the car is | Real-time 4G tracking; phone app alerts for suspicious activity; trip history; vehicle health alerts | Amazon |
| Viper 350 PLUS 3105V 1-Way Alarm | Installed alarm | Strong protection on a budget | 3-channel 1-way security with keyless entry; FailSafe starter kill; anti-carjacking and panic; six-tone siren | Amazon |
| Viper 3100V 1-Way Security System | Installed alarm | Simple wired protection | 2-stage shock sensor; door, hood and trunk protection; engine immobilization; parking light flash | Amazon |
| 115dB Vibration Car Alarm | Standalone alarm | Renters and quick deterrence | Vibration sensor; 115 dB alarm with LED strobe; 4-key remote; rechargeable lithium battery | Amazon |
The five security systems compared
How we chose: we compared these systems using the features each maker lists on Amazon (checked in November 2026), the type of protection they give and how they are installed. We have not tested them ourselves, so features below are as described by the manufacturer.
1. Viper 5706V 2-Way Security with Remote Start
A combined security and remote start system. Viper lists a 4-channel security system, a 5-button 2-way LCD remote and a range of up to one mile, so the remote can confirm commands and show alerts when the alarm is triggered.
It suits drivers who want both strong security and the convenience of starting the car from inside on cold or hot days.
Why it’s a good pick
- 2-way remote confirms alerts even when you can’t hear the siren
- Remote start adds everyday convenience
- Long listed range
Keep in mind
- Needs professional installation for most cars
- Costs more than 1-way alarms once installation is included
2. CARLOCK 4G Car Tracker and Alarm
CARLOCK is a tracker rather than a traditional alarm. According to the listing, it monitors the car and alerts your phone about suspicious behavior, tracks the car in real time over 4G, records trips, and can warn you about some vehicle health problems.
It’s the most useful option if you want to know immediately when something happens and be able to tell police where the car is. It can also help parents keep an eye on a new driver.
Why it’s a good pick
- Alerts reach your phone wherever you are
- Location tracking helps recovery after a theft
- No wiring into the alarm system
Keep in mind
- Doesn’t stop a thief from driving off
- Check the listing for any ongoing subscription cost
3. Viper 350 PLUS 3105V 1-Way Alarm
A 1-way alarm with keyless entry and two 4-button remotes. Viper lists a FailSafe starter kill, anti-carjacking and panic features, and a six-tone siren with parking light flash. Remote start and GPS tracking can be added as options.
It’s a good fit for an older car without a factory immobilizer, where a starter kill makes theft much harder.
Why it’s a good pick
- Starter kill stops the engine from being started
- Keyless entry included
- Can be expanded later
Keep in mind
- 1-way remote: no confirmation that the alarm went off
- Professional installation recommended
4. Viper 3100V 1-Way Security System
A straightforward wired alarm. The listing describes a 2-stage shock sensor (a warning chirp for light bumps and a full alarm for harder impacts), protection for the doors, hood and trunk, engine immobilization and parking light flash.
It covers the basics of an installed alarm without remote start or keyless-entry extras.
Why it’s a good pick
- Covers doors, hood and trunk
- 2-stage shock sensor reduces false alarms
- Includes engine immobilization
Keep in mind
- Fewer convenience features than the 350 PLUS
- Needs installation
5. 115dB Vibration Car Alarm
A self-contained, battery-powered alarm. The listing describes a vibration sensor, a 115 dB siren with a bright red LED strobe, a 4-key remote and a rechargeable lithium battery.
Because it doesn’t connect to the car’s wiring, it’s easy to fit to a car, RV or motorcycle and move between vehicles. It’s a visible deterrent rather than real protection.
Why it’s a good pick
- No wiring and no installer needed
- Bright strobe adds a visible warning
- Can be moved between vehicles
Keep in mind
- Doesn’t stop the engine or track the car
- Needs recharging
Verdict
For most drivers, an installed alarm with a starter kill gives the best protection for the money: the Viper 350 PLUS 3105V if you want value, or the Viper 5706V if you want 2-way alerts and remote start. Add a tracker like CARLOCK if getting a stolen car back matters most. The stick-on vibration alarm is a quick deterrent, not real security.
If your battery keeps going flat after an alarm is fitted, see our guide to what drains a car battery overnight, and keep a car emergency kit in the trunk.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- Manufacturer product listings for the Viper 5706V, Viper 350 PLUS 3105V, Viper 3100V, CARLOCK tracker and 115dB vibration alarm on Amazon.com (features checked November 2026)
- Car alarm (Wikipedia)
- Immobiliser (Wikipedia)
- Remote keyless system (Wikipedia)
- GPS tracking unit (Wikipedia)









